Strengthening the Governance of Technology Policy
Tuomas Pöysti, Senior Counsel at Geradin Partners, former Chancellor of Justice of Finland and an internationally recognised adviser on technology policy, led the preparation of a legal report commissioned by Technology Industries of Finland on strengthening the governance of technology policy in the Finnish Government. The question is relevant beyond Finland. Geopolitics increasingly shapes technology policy, and participation in EU decision making is central to the effectiveness of national technology policy. In Finland, responsibility for technology policy is currently divided between the Prime Minister’s Office and the ministries responsible for Finance, Transport and Communications, and Economic Affairs and Employment. The report concludes that strengthening the governance of technology policy requires tools that cover EU policy, national legislation, public funding and the steering of state agencies and state-owned companies.
The report adopts a broad understanding of technology policy, by identifying five areas, namely i) strategic technology priorities, including strategies and funding for strategic technologies and long-term programmes, ii) common rules, including technology-friendly legislation, rules for markets and the public sector, and the EU regulation, iii) digital infrastructure, covering both hardware and software, iv) the public sector as a user of technology and a shaper of markets, and v) technological resilience and cybersecurity. Technology policy understood in this way covers both the government’s own technology and digital operations and its action in markets and the private sector. Bringing these dimensions together departs from the current arrangement, in which they fall under different ministries.
The report identifies several conditions for effective governance of technology policy. Coordination requires formal powers and without them, the coordinating minister’s role remains largely political and the limits of that role unclear. The steering of government agencies and state-owned companies is an integral part of a ministry’s responsibility for the proper functioning of administration within its remit, and the two cannot be separated. Funding must also be secured under the responsible ministry, since in Finland every appropriation in the state budget belongs to a specific ministry, and joint government digital projects require a dedicated reserve within the spending limits. A ministry should, from the outset, have sufficient resources and a seat on the key ministerial committees. Finally, representation in the Council of the EU must be clearly allocated, as participation in EU decision making is central to the effectiveness of technology policy.
The report examines three models for organising the governance of technology policy, assessing each against the legislative and administrative work required, the timetable, the minister’s powers and position, and the main risks. Under Model A, a network model, a single minister handles technology and digital matters in the Prime Minister’s Office and three other ministries, with coordination led from the Prime Minister’s Office. It is the lightest and fastest to implement, but a risk is that the minister’s coordinating powers remain unclear. Model B establishes a new Ministry of Technology and Digital Affairs, which gives the clearest lines of accountability but is the heaviest to implement. Model C brings technology and digital matters together in the existing Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment, which would become a Ministry of Economic Affairs and Technology. It is heavier than Model A but lighter than Model B and links technology policy closely to growth policy. However, choosing between existing ministries may give rise to rivalry over status and power. The report finds no constitutional obstacle to any of the three models.
The report and its budget annex analyse Model B, a new Ministry of Technology and Digital Affairs, in the most detail. A separate ministry would concentrate preparation and steering responsibilities in one place, giving clear lines of accountability and a minister with formal powers as head of a ministry. It would also give technology and digital matters greater visibility and weight within government. The main disadvantage is the effort of implementation, which requires legislative amendments, a separate budget structure, staff transfers and a new administrative system, and may divert attention from policy itself. A small new ministry also risks limited influence, particularly if its minister does not sit on the key ministerial committees. To mitigate these risks, adequate funding and membership of ministerial committees should be secured when the ministry is established. In Finland, the new ministry would control net appropriations of about EUR 376 million on the basis of the 2027 budget proposal. Measured by budget alone, this would make it the smallest sector ministry, although the figure understates its steering responsibility for major agencies and state-owned companies.